Amy McElhenney was a former Miss Texas contestant turned Spanish teacher. The 25-year old was accused of having sexual relations with an 18-year old student. Although the student was of the age of consent, Texas has a law forbidding teachers to have relationships with students. While McElheney didn’t face jail time, she did lose her credentials as a teacher.
Debra Lafave was a teacher at Florida when she was charged with two felonies after having sexual relations with a 14-year old student. Lafave didn’t serve any jail time because the mother of the student didn’t want her son to go through a trial. Lafave is now happily married and a mother of twins.